A Fundamental Comparison of Concrete and Asphalt Pavement

When it comes time to choose between two of the most popular and constructive paving materials for your property, understanding their differences, advantages, and disadvantages is a wise step toward making the best investment decision. Continue reading to learn what makes asphalt difference from concrete, as well as some of the most common pros and cons of each paving material.

Asphalt Concrete Company Indianapolis Indiana 317-549-1833
Asphalt Concrete Company Indianapolis Indiana 317-549-1833

Asphalt and Concrete

Asphalt, also known as bitumen, is a dark bituminous pitch made from a combination of binder (usually refined liquid petroleum), filler, and aggregates like sand, gravel, stones, and grit. It is essentially crushed rock that has been heated and then cured into a hard, flat finish. Once cured, it is sealed with a seal coat, making it a non-permeable pavement that retains flexibility in order to withstand changing weather conditions and more.

Concrete is a man-made material prepared from cement, as well as certain aggregates like sand and gravel. It is a porous pavement, making it highly vulnerable to water permeation. After water enters the pores of the concrete, it will freeze and thaw with the changing seasons, which will cause cracks and other defects to surface in the following years.

Pros and Cons of Both

Take a look at some of the most common advantages and disadvantages of asphalt and concrete. This will give you an idea of what to expect, and perhaps help you make a wise buying decision. If you still have questions and concerns, your best course of action would be to talk to a licensed, bonded, and insured paving company for answers and advice you can trust.

Pros and Cons of Asphalt

Asphalt is easy to repair, cheaper to purchase, quicker to install (which also means cheaper labor costs) and is much better for the environment. It is widely noted for its sleek, smooth finishes and uniform appearances. On the other hand, asphalt has a lower lifespan than concrete. It is also less durable, requires ongoing maintenance, and can even soften in extreme heat conditions.

Pros and Cons of Concrete

Concrete is highly versatile and can be finished in an infinite array of colors, stains, scores, styles, and designs. It can even be made to imitate higher end materials, like brick, tile, and cobblestone. Compared to asphalt, it is more durable, can withstand extreme heat, and lasts much longer. However, concrete is more expensive to install and more difficult to repair. It is also prone to cracking in seasonal temperature fluctuations (freeze thaw cycles).

Do you have questions about your commercial paving needs? Contact ACI Asphalt and Concrete at 317-549-1833 for licensed, bonded, and insured pavement installation and repair in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Related Posts:

Top 3 Reasons Why is Asphalt More Popular Than Concrete
A Quick Comparison of Warm Mix Asphalt and Hot Mix Asphalt
Is it Possible to Lay Asphalt on Top of Concrete?

Top 3 Reasons Why is Asphalt More Popular Than Concrete

In modern construction, asphalt is one of the most fundamentally used materials for paving driveways, roads, parking lots, sidewalks, and more. It’s commonly used in place of concrete by contractors and property owners for a variety of reasons. Asphalt has several desirable features and qualities that makes it a better for many industrial and commercial paving projects.

Continue reading to learn the top three reasons why asphalt pavement is commonly preferred over concrete, plus how to get started with an estimate for asphalt paving in Central Indiana.

Asphalt Pavement Repair Company Indiana 317-549-1833
Asphalt Pavement Repair Company Indiana 317-549-1833

The Benefits of Asphalt are Ample

Although asphalt is a preferred form of paving, this doesn’t mean that concrete has no benefits or advantages. Depending on the project, one material may be better suited than the other; however, many paving project managers are using asphalt instead of concrete these days. Below are some of the most talked about advantages of using asphalt over concrete for commercial and industrial paving projects.

Low Initial Costs

Concrete, in the long run, costs less than asphalt pavement; however, the initial cost of installing asphalt is cheaper than concrete paving projects. This means it’s more economical than concrete as well. The only downfall to the initial cost affordable is that long-term maintenance care for asphalt is sometimes disregarded.

Time Efficiency

One of the most attractive features to asphalt is that it is more time efficient than concrete paving projects. Not only is it time effective, it’s also easy to apply and dries quicker than concrete. This means asphalt is the perfect approach for minor pavement repairs, such as potholes, cracks, and more. When it comes to paving projects or repair, saving time saves money on both ends.

Durability

There is a big difference between asphalt and concrete when it comes to durability, strength, and resilience. Concrete is more susceptible to damage and cracks much easier, making it much more prone to wear and tear, than asphalt paving. This means concrete also requires more maintenance and sealing then asphalt pavement does. Asphalt is also more weather resistant than concrete. It is resistant to normal or extreme climate changes, as well as harsh weather conditions and much more.

These reasons are just the start to why so many consumers choose asphalt for industrial or commercial pavement applications. It is highly recommended to consult your local Indianapolis commercial paving company for accurate and reliable information.

Are you looking for a trusted commercial paving company in your area? Contact ACI Asphalt and Concrete at 317-549-1833 to speak with a licensed contractor about commercial asphalt paving in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve clients all throughout the state.

Related Posts:

Why Asphalt Repairs are So Necessary
3 Benefits of Recycled Asphalt
Is it Possible to Lay Asphalt on Top of Concrete?

Will I Pay More For Asphalt or Concrete?

Cost comparisons play a vital role in all business-related expenditures, large or small. So, when it comes to paving new surfaces for your company, you will naturally want to know which pavement material is more cost-effective. Basically, you want to know if asphalt will cost you more than concrete, or vice versa. Scroll down to learn some facts about the cost of asphalt and concrete paving materials that will help you make the best spending decision for your business.

Commercial Pavement Company Indianapolis Indiana 317-549-1833
Commercial Pavement Company Indianapolis Indiana 317-549-1833

The Price of Asphalt Versus the Price of Concrete

Asphalt and concrete are two entirely different paving materials used to render the same types of paved structures. From roads and parking lots to courts, plazas, sidewalks, curbs, bollards, and more, both asphalt and concrete have proven to be tried and true paving products. But which one will cost you more, upfront and in the long run? The answer is complicated and more importantly, will vary depending on the unique details and specifications of your paving project. For this reason, lean on the facts about asphalt and concrete prices to help you get started in the right direction.

Let’s examine the pros and cons of both paving materials in terms of price and maintenance.

Average Prices

Asphalt is generally cheaper than concrete. That is why it is so widely used to pave roads, highways, and interstate systems. Oppositely, concrete tends to come with a high price tag. On average, asphalt can be procured between $1 and $5 per square foot (installed), while average concrete prices range between $3 and $10 per square foot installed.

Routine Maintenance

Although asphalt is the cheaper paving option upfront, it generates additional costs every 3 to 5 years when it needs resealing. A single bucket of asphalt sealant can cost upwards of $20, so you can imagine the total cost to reseal a multi-level parking lot or business front driveway. Without a proper sealcoat, asphalt will incur more damage, which can lead to premature repairs and overlays.

Concrete does not require much maintenance other than routine cleaning, pressure washing, and if applicable, fresh paint application. However, concrete cracks tend to be a challenging repair, and therefore, pricey. That is something to think about when deciding on a paving material.

Square Footage

Because asphalt and concrete are typically priced by the square foot, installed, the size of your project will largely impact the total cost of paving. The more surface area, the higher the cost, both upfront and in the long run.

Lifespan

Concrete pavements can last between 20 and 60 years with good care. Asphalt pavements can last between 10 and 30 years with regular sealcoating and good care.

Are you looking for qualified road construction and commercial paving in Central Indiana? Contact ACI Asphalt and Concrete at 317-549-1833 for licensed and insured paving services for asphalt and concrete pavements in Indianapolis, Indiana. We serve commercial and industrial clients all throughout such parts of the state.

Related Posts:

A Quick Comparison of Warm Mix Asphalt and Hot Mix Asphalt
Which Paving Material Performs Better in Winter?
Primary Factors Used to Calculate the Cost of Asphalt Sealcoating

Which Paving Material Performs Better in Winter?

In most cases of developing or restoring a property, pavement is going to be an important factor. From sidewalks and driveways, to patios, parking lots, ADA ramps, and more, paving generally plays a large role in real estate construction and renovation. This time of year, proprietors are asking questions about pavement installation, including which paving material is a better choice for winter weather conditions.

Continue reading to find out what you need to know about choosing a paving material for your construction project this season.

Indiana Commercial Paving
Indiana Commercial Paving 317-549-1833

Asphalt or Concrete?

The two primary categories of pavement are asphalt and concrete, both of which retain separate qualities and properties, as well as, contain a list of sub-categories of paving materials. It is important to understand the differences and similarities among the paving options available to choose the best material for your property.

Asphalt Options

There are three main types of asphalt materials to choose from. These include hot-mix asphalt, cold-mix asphalt, and UPM asphalt. There is also warm asphalt mix.

Hot mix asphalt is poured at a high temperature of 300 to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, and is only applied when outdoor temperatures exceed 40 degrees Fahrenheit because it cools so rapidly. In the United States, it is the most common method of asphalt paving used for high-traffic pavements like highways, roads, interstates, and more.

Warm mix asphalt is manufactured and shipped at lower temperatures, usually between 200 and 250 degrees Fahrenheit, and it has a slower cooling rate than HMA. This means it can be used in colder seasons or climates for road, highway, and interstate construction. 

Cold patch asphalt is emulsified in water using soap, and then mixed with an aggregate, usually concrete, to render a stronger, more durable paving material. It is mostly used to fill potholes on a year-round basis. There are various grades, all designed for specific climates. There is a specially-formulated winter grade for temperatures of 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below, a spring and fall grade for temperatures between 40 and 60 degrees Fahrenheit, and a summer mix for temperatures between 60 and 80 degrees Fahrenheit.

UPM® permanent patching material is manufactured by the company, Unique Paving Materials, hence the acronym “UPM.” Although one of the most popular products, there are various brands offered on the market aside from UPM® permanent patching material, such as EZ Street® and Aquaphalt®.

Concrete Options

There are several different types and grades of concrete available. The type chosen depends on the application and similar factors. Common concrete options include normal strength concrete, plain or ordinary concrete, reinforced concrete, pre-stressed concrete, precast concrete, light-weight concrete, high-density concrete, and air-entrained concrete. Grade options range in ratios of cement, sand, and aggregates, from M5 to M70.

Talk to a Paving Professional in Indianapolis

Call ACI Asphalt and Concrete at 317-549-1833 for commercial and municipal paving services in Indianapolis, Indiana. Our licensed and qualified paving contractors provide several Indianapolis asphalt and concrete paving services, including pavement repair, sealcoating, road work, commercial paving, industrial paving, winter cold patching, and more. We are the industry veterans to trust for skilled craftsmanship and competitive prices! Request a free estimate, today.